World Tourism Case Study Response

Introduction

Tourism is one of the most dynamic and impactful industries in the global economy, connecting people, cultures, and ecosystems across continents. It drives economic growth, fosters cross-cultural understanding, and funds critical conservation efforts. However, as the case studies of ecotourism in Africa, cruise tourism in Alaska, and mountain tourism in Nepal illustrate, the rapid growth of tourism presents complex challenges. These include environmental degradation, cultural displacement, and unsustainable resource consumption. As global citizens and hospitality management professionals, we act as stewards of this robust industry, ensuring tourism thrives while preserving the natural and cultural assets underpinning its success. By balancing economic benefits with sustainability and community involvement, we can create a tourism industry that supports present and future generations.

Cruise Tourism: Alaska

Growth in Cruise Tourism and Economic Impact in Alaska

In 2008, Skagway, Alaska, welcomed approximately 6,000 cruise ship visitors daily, with cruise passengers contributing over $160 million per day to Southeast Alaska's economy. By 2024, cruise tourism in Skagway has grown substantially, with projections of 1.2 million passengers per year (KTOO, 2023). This translates to an average of over 6,500 daily visitors during the cruise season, surpassing 2008 figures. Similarly, Juneau, another key port in Southeast Alaska, reported $320 million in cruise passenger spending in 2023 (Alaska Public Media, 2024). Although precise regional spending data for 2024 is unavailable, the dramatic increase in passenger numbers indicates a significant economic boost compared to previous years.

Flags of Convenience: Impact on Taxes and Labor Standards in Alaska

Cruise ships often operate under "flags of convenience" (FOCs), registering in countries with open registries to benefit from lower taxes and less stringent labor regulations. This allows cruise lines to reduce tax liabilities by shifting profits to low-tax jurisdictions, minimizing contributions to the U.S. tax base, including Alaska (Avagyan, 2019). While this practice financially benefits cruise companies, it impacts states hosting cruise operations. FOCs have also been associated with relaxed labor standards, raising concerns about employee welfare. However, a University of Piraeus study found no significant difference in welfare between FOC-registered ships and those under national flags, suggesting improved working conditions or greater standardization across the industry (TradeWinds, 2021).

Improvements in Cruise Ship Emissions

Since 2008, the cruise industry has made strides in reducing emissions, driven by international regulations and technological advances. The International Maritime Organization (IMO) introduced the "IMO 2020" regulation, which reduced the sulfur content of marine fuels to 0.5%, cutting sulfur oxide emissions by 85% (Skift, 2019). Additionally, the IMO aims to reduce the carbon intensity of international shipping by at least 40% by 2030 compared to 2008 levels (IMO, n.d.). Cruise companies have adopted various measures to meet goals, including using liquefied natural gas (LNG) as a cleaner fuel alternative. Carnival Corporation, for example, has incorporated LNG into new vessels to achieve net carbon-neutral operations (The Times, 2024). Hurtigruten Expeditions has introduced hybrid-powered ships and eliminated single-use plastics to minimize environmental impacts further. However, despite these efforts, the industry's rapid growth has offset some gains, and progress in decarbonization remains modest (The Guardian, 2024). Continued investment in sustainable technology and stricter regulations remains critical.

Managing Overcrowding: Juneau’s Passenger Limit

To manage the challenges associated with increased tourism, Juneau, Alaska, has implemented measures to address overcrowding. Starting in 2026, the city will cap daily cruise ship passengers at 16,000 on most days and 12,000 on Saturdays (KTOO, 2024). This policy aims to alleviate strain on local infrastructure and preserve residents' quality of life. Such limits represent a thoughtful approach to balancing economic benefits with environmental and social sustainability. While cruise tourism is a vital economic driver, unregulated growth can harm natural ecosystems, overburden public services, and negatively impact community well-being. By establishing passenger caps, Juneau seeks to ensure that tourism remains a positive force, benefiting both visitors and locals for the long term.

Mountain Tourism: Nepal

The economic benefits of tourism are undeniable, as seen in the examples of Alaska’s booming cruise industry and Nepal’s reliance on trekking tourism. In Alaska, cruise tourism generates billions in revenue, bolsters local economies, and creates jobs in remote communities. Similarly, tourism in Nepal is vital for economic development, particularly in underserved mountainous regions, where it provides livelihoods and promotes infrastructure growth. However, unregulated tourism's environmental and cultural costs demand attention in both cases. Overcrowding, habitat degradation, and resource exploitation highlight the necessity for sustainable tourism practices to balance economic growth with ecological preservation.

Economic and Employment Benefits

Tourism in Nepal, particularly in areas like Sagarmatha National Park, home to Mount Everest, offers significant benefits. Economically, it is a key foreign currency source, strengthening the nation's financial stability. The influx of international visitors supports local businesses such as hotels, restaurants, and handicraft industries, enhancing residents' livelihoods (Nepal Trek Adventures, n.d.). The sector also generates substantial employment. In 2019, tourism accounted for over one million direct and indirect jobs, comprising roughly 6.7% of Nepal's total employment. About 80% of these opportunities are in remote, resource-limited areas, offering critical income sources with scarce alternatives (World Bank, 2022). Additionally, tourism has driven infrastructure development in mountainous regions, improving accessibility and boosting economic activity. Improved roads and facilities benefit tourists and local communities, fostering progress in these hard-to-reach areas (Rai et al., 2021).

Environmental Challenges and Solutions

While tourism has undeniable advantages, its environmental and cultural impacts cannot be ignored. For instance, Namche Bazaar has long relied on firewood to heat water, contributing to deforestation. However, recent initiatives have sought to address this issue. Adopting solar-powered water heating systems in teahouses and lodges has significantly reduced firewood consumption, helping preserve local forests. These systems have also created opportunities for rural artisans to acquire new skills, promoting sustainable practices (Sharma et al., 2019). Similarly, improved cookstoves, supported by organizations like WWF, have enhanced fuel efficiency, further easing pressure on forests and improving daily life for residents (WWF, 2017).

Despite these efforts, challenges persist. Limited road infrastructure hampers the transportation of alternative fuels, leaving many areas reliant on wood as their primary energy source. Sustained efforts are essential to promote renewable energy solutions and minimize the environmental impact of tourism in Nepal’s mountainous regions.

Waste Management and Rubbish Bonds

Efforts to manage waste accumulation on Mount Everest have also gained momentum in recent years, yielding successes and ongoing challenges. Cleanup campaigns have played a critical role, such as a month-long initiative that removed over 22,000 pounds of trash, later recycled into raw materials for other products (Waste360, 2018). Similarly, the 2023 Mountain Clean-up Campaign collected more than 34,166 kilograms of waste in just 45 days, highlighting the problem's magnitude and the commitment to addressing it (The Himalayan Times, 2023).

Technological innovations are also being employed to tackle waste. Nepalese officials have tested drones capable of transporting waste from high altitudes, showing promise in Everest’s challenging conditions (The Times, 2023). Additionally, the "rubbish bond" system, as described by climber Rob Hall, requires climbers to deposit a refundable fee as an incentive to return their waste. However, while this system has been in place for some time, its effectiveness remains inconsistent due to the harsh conditions and the sheer number of climbers (Discover Magazine, 2023).

The global tourism industry must also address the growing challenge of waste management and carbon emissions. From cleanup campaigns on Mount Everest to the cruise industry’s adoption of cleaner fuel alternatives, there is a clear need for innovative, long-term solutions. Efforts like Nepal’s solar-powered heating systems and the International Maritime Organization’s emission reduction regulations demonstrate the potential for tourism to adopt greener practices. These examples highlight that sustainability is not just an ideal but a practical necessity for the industry’s survival.

In conclusion, tourism in Nepal’s mountainous regions is vital to economic development, job creation, and infrastructure improvement. While solar energy adoption and cleanup campaigns have addressed environmental challenges, more work is needed. Continuous innovation and long-term strategies will ensure that tourism remains sustainable and beneficial for Nepal's communities and natural heritage sites.

Ecotourism: Africa

Economic and Conservation Impacts of Ecotourism

Ecotourism has become a critical African strategy for conserving endangered species, particularly mountain gorillas. By drawing tourists to natural habitats, ecotourism generates revenue that directly funds conservation efforts and provides significant economic benefits to local communities. This financial incentive often fosters a protective attitude toward wildlife. In Rwanda, tourism revenue is allocated to community development projects, improving infrastructure and services (Condé Nast Traveler, 2020).

Challenges of Ecotourism

However, ecotourism comes with challenges. The close genetic relationship between humans and gorillas increases the risk of disease transmission, threatening these vulnerable populations. Additionally, frequent tourist interactions can disrupt animal behaviors and degrade natural habitats if not carefully managed. The influx of tourists also has cultural implications, sometimes contributing to the erosion of local traditions and lifestyles (PMC, n.d.).

Despite these challenges, ecotourism has demonstrated its potential for success when prioritizing sustainability and community involvement. Ecotourism can support conservation and cultural preservation by implementing strict environmental guidelines and ensuring local communities benefit directly from tourism. For instance, Uganda's Bwindi Impenetrable National Park has successfully reduced tensions between park authorities and local communities through controlled resource harvesting agreements and revenue-sharing programs, increasing local participation in gorilla protection efforts (PMC, n.d.).

Balancing Conservation and Tourism: Lessons from Rosette Rugamba

Other African ecotourism initiatives, such as Kenya's community-based conservancies, have similarly balanced wildlife conservation with sustainable development. These models often involve landowners leasing property for conservation and tourism, providing a stable income while preserving natural habitats. These efforts highlight the critical role of community engagement and diversified land use in achieving long-term conservation goals (Condé Nast Traveler, 2020).

Rosette Rugamba’s assertion that “you cannot conserve if you are over-exploiting what you have” underscores the delicate balance between tourism and conservation. While tourism has bolstered Rwanda’s economy and funded conservation initiatives, it has also contributed to environmental challenges. According to the World Bank (2023), environmental degradation, including deforestation and habitat fragmentation, poses significant risks to Rwanda’s wildlife. The construction of tourism-related infrastructure, such as hotels and roads, often exacerbates these problems by disrupting ecosystems (World Bank Group).

Tourism's impact on habitats is evident elsewhere in Africa. In Tanzania's Ngorongoro Crater, the daily influx of vehicles has led to noise pollution, habitat degradation, and disruptions to wildlife behaviors. Such issues highlight the importance of responsible tourism management in minimizing ecological harm (Geographical Magazine).

To address these negative impacts, sustainable tourism practices must be prioritized. This includes regulating the number of tourists, ensuring that infrastructure development adheres to eco-friendly standards, and actively involving local communities in conservation efforts. With these strategies in place, tourism can continue to support conservation while avoiding the overexploitation of natural resources.

Ecotourism in Africa further underscores the critical role tourism can play in conservation. Ecotourism has become a cornerstone of conservation efforts by generating revenue for wildlife protection and incentivizing communities to safeguard natural habitats, especially for endangered species like mountain gorillas. However, it also reveals how improper management can harm the ecosystems it seeks to protect. Disease transmission, habitat fragmentation, and cultural erosion are pressing concerns, emphasizing the need for hospitality professionals to prioritize sustainability and minimize tourism's ecological footprint.

In conclusion, while ecotourism in Africa provides substantial conservation and economic benefits, its success depends on careful management to mitigate adverse effects on wildlife, habitats, and local cultures. Sustainability and community involvement are essential to ensure that ecotourism remains a force for good, balancing economic growth with preserving Africa’s natural and cultural heritage.

Conclusion

As these case studies demonstrate, the global tourism industry is both a driver of progress and a potential source of harm. The economic benefits it generates are substantial but have significant environmental and cultural responsibilities. It is imperative that society, and particularly those in the hospitality management field, act as stewards of tourism, ensuring that this robust industry contributes positively to the world. By embracing sustainable practices, fostering community engagement, and leveraging innovation, we can address the challenges posed by tourism and transform them into opportunities for growth and preservation. Tourism has the potential to inspire, connect, and sustain humanity and the planet—if managed thoughtfully and responsibly. The future of global tourism depends on our collective commitment to sustainability, and as professionals, we are uniquely positioned to lead the way.

Works Cited

Alaska Public Media. (2024, April 8). Juneau had a record-breaking cruise season last year.  This year should be about the same. Alaska Public Media.

Avagyan, A. (2019). Addressing the criticism on flags of convenience. Southwestern Journal of International Law, 28(1), 129-147.

Condé Nast Traveler. (2020, November 23). In Kenya, community initiatives are redefining conservation. Condé Nast Traveler.

Discover Magazine. (2023, May 16). The history of Everest expeditions and their waste problem. Discover Magazine.

Geographical Magazine. (2023). Gone wild: is wildlife tourism out of control? Geographical Magazine.

International Maritime Organization. (n.d.). Improving the energy efficiency of ships. IMO.

KTOO. (2023, March 30). Record number of cruise passengers expected in Skagway this year. KTOO.

KTOO. (2024, May 31). With cruise tourism booming, Juneau has negotiated a limit on how many passengers can come off ships. KTOO.

Nepal Trek Adventures. (n.d.). Tourism in Nepal - Importance, advantages, scope, statistics of tourism. Nepal Trek Adventures.

PMC. (n.d.). Gorilla conservation and disease transmission risks. National Center for Biotechnology Information.

Rai, S. C., Sundriyal, P., & Sharma, E. (2021). Tourism-related facility development in Sagarmatha (Mount Everest) National Park, Nepal. Land, 10(9), 925.

Sharma, S., Zahnd, A., & Gross, T. (2019). Efficient fuelwood consumption with innovative solar water-heating systems in the middle hills of Nepal. Mountain Research and Development, 39(2), R41-R49.

Skift. (2019, October 31). The cruise industry will soon face its strictest pollution standard yet. Skift.

The Guardian. (2024, November 28). Can you take a clean cruise holiday and which vessels are the worst emitters? The Guardian.

The Himalayan Times. (2023, May 12). Mountain Clean-Up Campaign removes over 34,000 kilograms of waste. The Himalayan Times.

The Times. (2024, January 20). 11 of the world's most sustainable cruise lines. The Times.

TradeWinds. (2021, March 31). Study: Seafarers see 'no difference' in welfare in flags of convenience and national flags. TradeWinds.

Waste360. (2018, August 22). Recycling Everest: Cleaning up 22,000 pounds of trash from the world's highest peak. Waste360.

World Bank. (2023). Gorillas just part of the mix: To expand, nature-based tourism in Rwanda needs other activities too. World Bank.

World Bank. (2022, June 3). Harnessing tourism to enhance the value of biodiversity and promote conservation in Nepal. World Bank.

WWF. (2017, March 7). In Nepal, cook stoves improve lives and help the environment. Climatelinks.